Gas Geyser or Solar Geyser
Solar Geysers have the advantage of making use of the sun, a free resource but can fall short on cloudy days and do not have an “endless” supply of hot water. Gas Geysers will keep producing hot water as long as there is a supply of gas, the problem comes when you run out of gas and gas costs money to buy while the sun is free. The best would be to get both and take make use of the advantages of both by making use of solar compatible Gas Geysers.
Solar Is Free
The obvious advantage of solar water heating is that its free, mostly reliable and does not require much maintenance. The problems with solar are:
- The hot water runs out/becomes cold as you use it. meaning the last person to have a shower may have a cold shower.
- On cloudy days the geyser may use electricity to heat up water, bad if there is no electricity.
- Evacuated tubes can be hit by hail making them useless.
- There might not be hot water in the morning if you decide not to connect the electricity.
Other than that solar is really great and can greatly reduce your electricity bill dramatically if you can fit your lifestyle into its cycle. A nice advantage to solar over gas is that you don’t need to keep buying gas bottles and have the inconvenience of having to transport heavy gas bottles continually.
Gas Is More Convenient
Solar may be free but when the hot water runs out you are going to have to bite the bullet and join the lukewarm shower club. Gas geysers however do not have that problem (as long as you have gas), you can shower one after the other without having to stress if the hot water will run out. Additionally, a gas geyser will produce hot water at a more constant/stable temperature where the water temperature from a solar geyser will continually decrease as you use it. Gas geysers are generally cheaper to run than electricity (depending on electricity costs), many people can see huge savings if their cost per unit is high (our cost per unit is relatively low so our savings are not so pronounced as others). The problems with gas are:
- Constantly having to buy new gas bottles.
- Unpredictable gas shortages.
If Convenience is important to you, like having hot water during load shedding, then a Gas Geyser is for you. You can still make savings on your electrical bill and you have that added convenience factor.
Having both is better
If you want the savings of solar but the convenience of gas, you can just combine the 2 and have the best of both worlds. There are newer gas geysers on the market today that are not as expensive as fan forced gas geysers but are still solar compatible. These units do not cost significantly more than the normal diaphragm geysers and the installation for these units will be cheaper than that of a fan forced unit.
An alternative approach
One other way route you can go is getting a heat pump. A heat pump is able to take the heat from the ambient air and heat your water, so you put 1kw of electrical power in and get out 4-5kw of heat in the form of hot water. Essentially this is still solar powered because the sun heats up the ambient air but it does require some electricity.
If it was me and I had some money lying around I would get a 3kw grid-tie solar inverter system (with an export limiter) plus a heat pump and run my heat pump during the day for free.
This has a few advantages:
- when there is no sun you can still heat water very efficiently
- no need to get gas bottles
- When the water has reached temperature you can make use of 3kw worth or power during the day which you would not be able to do with a solar thermal system, this is probably the best reason to go with this solution.
the obvious disadvantage is that you would be without hot water when there is no power, but you could easily get a "cheap" gas geyser installed as a backup.