What’s the best gas stove to buy?

AD

When it comes to buying a gas stove, getting the right balance of reliability, functionality, and value for money is key. Previously, we did not include Defy due to past quality concerns and a high number of DOA (Dead on Arrival) appliances. However, there has been a drastic change since then, and Defy units are now some of the best bang-for-buck appliances you can buy. Other reliable brands include Elba, Bosch, and Smeg.

The most expensive is not always the best

Don't think that picking the most expensive unit you see is automatically going to translate into better quality and longevity. Though it is mostly true, many gas stoves come out with exactly the same burners from SABAF, so don't think the burners are any better on more expensive stoves. However, you may want to try and get a stove with SABAF burners (just look at the removable metal pieces on top of the stove). If it is a SABAF burner, it will have a SABAF logo on it, and they are the better variety of burners compared to others.

Cheaper burners can be noisy, and sometimes the flame "jumps" from the burner because it is getting too much oxygen. This is fixable by setting the amount of gas getting fed to the burner, but that requires partial dismantling of the stove. Speaking for our company, we do not want to dismantle a client's brand-new stove to do adjustments in case we potentially void a warranty or break the stove. The brands that have the worst flame jumping are AEG and Whirlpool (Whirlpool hobs). We have had one Bosch stove that had a flame-jumping problem, but only one. AEG has it the worst, while Whirlpool is not as bad. All that being said, the problem is fixable with some adjustment.

Choose a reputable brand

Choose a unit from a good brand as they are more likely to keep spares in case something breaks down the road. The brands we mentioned are going to keep spares for a long time, so if something does break, at least you can get a replacement part. Some brands are here today and gone tomorrow.

Brands we think are good (in order):

These are the brands that we think are good based on our experience working with them and installing them over the years. There are other brands out there, but we just don’t have that much experience with them to give a solid recommendation. If you want to get something that is going to last a very long time, consider spending more and get a Smeg or explore Elba and La Germania's high-end ranges. Bosch, Elba, and Defy also offer great quality and competitive pricing.

Which is the best stove to buy?

Budget & Entry-Level Options

If you are looking for great value without breaking the bank, here are two excellent entry-level choices:

  1. Defy Black 4 Burner Gas Stove (DGS168)

A fantastic budget choice now that Defy's manufacturing quality has dramatically improved.

Features: 4 burners, no electric ignition (needs a lighter for both top and oven), no grill, sturdy base (level floor required), and no electrical connection at all.

How the oven works: The gas oven in this stove is very simple; the knob is simply a gas flow regulator, and the temperature settings written on the stove may not be very accurate. It gets the job done, but baking may be difficult without an oven thermometer for exact temperatures.

DGS568

View the Defy DGS168 on Hirsch's (not sponsored)

  1. Elba 60cm Essential 4 Burner Cooker with Gas Oven (66/CL442GN)

If you can afford to spend a bit more, this is a big step up in oven functionality and convenience (roughly double the price of the basic Defy model).

Features: Electric ignition (a lighter is only necessary during loadshedding), top grill, and more accurate temperature control via a thermostatic gas valve. Requires an electrical connection for the ignition (optional).

How the gas oven works: The burner is lit and burns at max gas flow until the target temperature is reached, then automatically decreases the gas flow to prevent overheating.

66CL442GN

View the Elba 60cm Essential on Hirsch's (not sponsored)

Midrange: Elba Essential 90CM 5 Gas Cooker with Gas Oven (04/96CL828BN)

We have had no bad experiences with Elba over the years; they are perfect for someone who is looking for quality without breaking the bank too much. Essentially a larger, 90cm version of the 66/CL442GN featuring 5 gas burners, auto ignition, flame failure safety, and a double-burner thermostatic gas oven. (Remember to be very careful when moving the stove—it basically needs to be lifted rather than slid on the ground).

0496CL828BN

View the Elba 90cm Essential on Hirsch's (not sponsored)

Expansive: Anything Smeg, Elba and La Germania's High-End Range

If you have the budget and want a top-tier stove, go for Smeg, or look into Elba and La Germania's high-end ranges. They are among the best brands available, offering exceptional build quality. Just know that your food will taste the same, and with Smeg you still have to deal with those flimsy legs—but they represent the highest quality out of them all.

The stove you buy must be approved by your local authority

All gas appliances sold in South Africa must be listed on the Safe Appliance Database. Being on the list means that the appliance has been tested to meet certain safety criteria. A gas stove being on this list does not guarantee that it is a good stove, but it is a good start. If the gas stove you are looking to buy is not on this list, try to contact the importers to see if they have the permits (it can take time for the online list to be updated); otherwise, do not buy it.

LPGas Safe Appliance Database

Buying a compliant stove is only half of it - somebody still has to connect it. We only fit appliances that are on the Safe Appliance List, we pipe and pressure test the connection, and we issue the Certificate of Compliance for the installation. If you are in Boksburg, our gas installers in Boksburg fit free-standing stoves, built-in ovens and glass hobs - see gas stove installation for what is included in the price.

AD
AD
Share this post:

Related Articles

All posts